Calling for Brave Leadership in the Climate Era
Imagine you're the captain of a massive ship. You've spotted dangerous waters ahead, but changing course means disrupting your passengers' champagne dinner. Most captains today are choosing to rearrange the deck chairs, and draft strongly worded memos about maritime safety. Meanwhile, the iceberg looms.
Let's be clear: Changing course isn't easy. The crew is comfortable with their routines, the shareholders expect their smooth-sailing dividends, and frankly, it's hard to be the captain who ruins dinner. But we know what happens to ships that prioritize temporary comfort over necessary action.
The environmental challenges we face—from biodiversity collapse to climate injustice—aren't distant threats on the horizon anymore. They're here; we are living it. Yet in many boardrooms across the globe, the response remains painfully predictable: another strategy document, another net-zero pledge, another set of targets conveniently set for 2030, 2050, and beyond.
Yes, we have global treaties in place. Yes, we have ESG goals. And yes, humankind has the technological prowess to get us to net zero. But let's face it—what's holding us back isn't a lack of solutions. It's a lack of decisions. Decisions that can only come from bold, brave leaders.
We need leaders daring enough to plot an entirely new course, challenge the fundamental assumptions of modern business, and pioneer ways of creating value that serve both planet and profit. We need leaders who have the courage to turn the ship now, even if they are the first captain to break formation.
An uncomfortable truth
Today, most sustainability initiatives fail not because of a lack of technology or resources, but because of leadership paralysis. We're witnessing three critical traps that keep organizations stuck.
The first is the quarterly trap, where even well-intentioned leaders find themselves caught between climate commitments and earnings expectations. Watch any earnings call, and you'll hear the tension: ambitious sustainability goals carefully balanced against short-term financial targets. It's like trying to change course while keeping everyone's champagne glasses from spilling; this balancing act keeps us frozen in place.
Then there's innovation theater, where organizations launch sustainability programs that look transformative, but stop short of making fundamental change. The bottled water industry is a perfect example; it highlights recycled plastic bottles and "eco-friendly" packaging, but doesn't address the fundamental waste of bottling and shipping water globally when most developed nations have clean tap water. It's like tying down those deck chairs while avoiding the bigger conversation.
Finally, there's delegation delusion. Over the past year, I've met dozens of brilliant CSOs with ambitious plans, but sustainability can't be delegated to a department, no matter how capable its leader. Imagine trying to digitally transform a company by creating a "digital department," while everyone else works on paper. Real transformation requires sustainability to be woven into every decision, from the boardroom to the factory floor.
The new leadership imperative
Despite all these traps, change is happening. There are brave leaders out there—few, but growing—who are making incredible impact. At IDEO, we're fortunate to partner, work, and be friends with some of these pioneers, and I've noticed distinct patterns in how they lead. Here's what brave climate leadership looks like:
1. Embracing discomfort
When Allbirds stamped all of its products with their carbon footprint—like a nutrition label for the planet—the company made their environmental impact as visible as their price tag. This radical transparency forced the company to completely rethink its design and manufacturing, leading to the world's first carbon-negative EVA foam in footwear. And Allbirds didn't stop there. The company open-sourced its carbon footprint tools to other companies, making it possible for other companies to share their impact.
2. Reinventing the core business
Recently, I sat down with a leader from a world-leading consumer technology company who told me, "The future I see looks nothing like our current product line. And I'm ready to build that future, even if it means dismantling what drives our profits today." This willingness to reimagine the company’s foundation extends to how it operates. Smart leaders are putting sustainability targets on equal footing with financial ones in executive compensation—because real change happens when missing a climate goal hurts as much as missing a profit target.
3. Creating better products that happen to be sustainable
Method's concentrated cleaning products show how sustainability can drive innovation. By removing the water (which consumers have at home, anyway), the company created products that save money through reduced shipping and storage costs, while simultaneously cutting carbon emissions from transportation and using less packaging material. Customers choose their products because they're simply better, and they happen to use less water and plastic. There’s no compromise—only added benefit.
4. Making bold bets on the future
Let's be honest—it's daunting to reinvent an entire supply chain or revamp your existing infrastructure to become sustainable . But when CVS Health, Target, and Walmart decided to create the "Beyond the Bag" challenge, aimed at eliminating plastic bags, they showed the entire retail industry what's possible. But taking bold bets isn't just about changing your own operations. Over the past years, I've met incredible young female leaders like Dr. Anne Schauer-Gimenez from Mango Materials and Julia Marsh from Sway, who are revolutionizing how we think about materials. Smart leaders aren't waiting for these solutions to be proven at scale—they're actively investing in and scaling them themselves. Because one day soon, the choice won't be whether to change, but whether you still can.
5. Having fun doing It
Look at Rewiring America's approach to electrification. Instead of another doom-and-gloom climate message or boring, beige-colored Times New Roman ESG reports, they're making home electrification feel electric. Their tools—including an easy-to-use calculator and a personal electrification planner—don't just show carbon savings—they show families how much money they'll save by switching to heat pumps and induction stoves. When I recently connected with their VP of Product Tom Mercer, his energy about electrifying millions of low-income houses was contagious. And it's no accident that the company's head of marketing cofounded Upworthy and served as managing editor of The Onion—this fresh perspective brings wit and humor to what could be a dry technical topic. Sometimes saving the planet is fun.
6. Listen to customers—for real
As a design director at IDEO, I spend countless hours supporting our design teams in research sessions, listening to people talk about their everyday choices. And let me tell you—the narrative that "people don't care about sustainability" is not just wrong, it's dangerous business thinking. The next generation isn't just asking for better options—they're demanding them. They're reading labels, questioning materials, and calling out greenwashing on social media. Deloitte's 2024 research shows 64 percent of Gen Z will pay more for sustainable products, and 25 percent have cut ties with businesses over unsustainable practices. This isn't about a small group of eco-warriors anymore—this is mainstream consumer behavior shifting before our eyes. Miss these signals, and you'll miss the future of your market. Just ask the fashion brands being called out daily on social media, or the consumer goods companies watching their market share shift to sustainable alternatives.
The real work starts now
It's inspiring to hear about startups and innovators blazing new trails. But the real challenge—and opportunity—lies in transforming century-old organizations. We don't need more sustainability strategies. We need leaders from every industry to become the brave new captains of the climate era
The climate crisis offers a stark choice for leaders: Be brave enough to transform your organization now, or watch it become irrelevant in a world that's already changing. At IDEO, we're energized by leaders ready to make this transformation. If you're ready to design solutions that will define the next era of business, we'd love to work with you to bring that vision to life. Let's create meaningful change together.
Get in touch